Napa DeMonk: an evening on Mars thanks to the Bloomington Playwrights Project

*edit* Check the comments for clarification as to who put the show on */edit*
Napa DeMonk was not my ideal Martian Colonial Era Terraforming Opera.
That I walked in to the theater with an ideal Martian Colonial Era Terraforming Opera in my head probably tells you that I was predisposed to like it anyway. You should listen to that voice. It could have been written by Ed Wood and performed by the Saint Abby’s Refuge for the Critically Tone Death’s choir and I would have managed to like it. Happily it was written competently and sung by a number of talented singers. Add to that a really cool slide show to set the mood as the opera goes on.
I don’t know if it was always on purpose, but there were more than a few awesome shadow silhouettes on the globe of mars on the side of the stage.

I assume the show started right on time since I was, of course, running late. I wasn’t the only one to get there after the start, and we waited for a pause in the music to enter. I sort of sat on the risers for the first (and longest) act then wandered up to a center seat toward the back of the hall at the intermission. (For music, assuming there is a decent sound system, I like to sit near the center of the room, back from the speakers a bit. It paid off this time.) I always have a hard time following a story done in song, but happily the program had a lengthy synopsis that helped a lot. The story was more the back story of Green Hills of Earth than John Carter of Mars, more the troubles of an established but not yet independant colony, the day to day people that become the myths of three generations hence (not the Green Hills of Earth the poem, but the stories of the travels of the blind bard who wrote it.) Oh, or Harrison’s old novella Planet Story. It dealt with the personal scale people who the future remembers of heroes even if they were actually bums.
I’m a bit of a planetology and terraforming snob, so there were some bits of the science that bugged me a bit, but I told those bits to sit down and shut up while I was listening to the wonderful music. And I’m not going to let them come out here either.
Every once in a while the lyrics got a little clumsy, but since the only English Language Opera I’ve listened to is Gilbert and Sullivan, everyone’s lyrics are most likely a little clumsy from time to time, and except for G&S I listen to opera mostly to be engulfed by the music, not to nitpick the lyrics, and as a writer, eventually you have to quit letting the perfect get in the way of the good.

It was an excellent show, on a beautiful night, a few minor flaws, but from a community theater group where I am paying 5 dollars for a ticket, I don’t expect or want perfection. I want an enjoyable evening with pretty music, interesting stage craft, and a story that keeps me awake while I sit there with my eyes shut to listen better. I got all that plus a bit of Resnikian myth building. All in all an excellent show.

Advertisement

4 Responses to “Napa DeMonk: an evening on Mars thanks to the Bloomington Playwrights Project”

  1. Chad Says:

    I enjoyed it too! But please note that this was not a Bloomington Playwrights Project production. It was a rental, so Julian Livingston and his talented crew deserve all the credit!

  2. Julian Says:

    I really wish roninkakuhito would let us know the problems with the terraforming science in opera, not program written by others. I am a member of the Planetary Society, the Martian Underground, and AAAS, plus DMTS of Bell Labs, and likewise follow such matters closely. I will clean up accordingly.

    Thanks for good review roninkakuhito!

    Composer Livingston

  3. Julian Says:

    -

  4. roninkakuhito Says:

    This is sort of my culture blog, so I don’t want to get into a long technical debate here, but it was mostly something I took as a plot point. I don’t think it needs fixing, it just caught at my attention. This is a back of the envelope treatment, completely unsourced. The CO2 in the canyons and caves is useful for the story, but problematic otherwise. Martian surface pressure is approximately .006 ATM. With our standard air mix, you need more than .33 atm of pressure to be active (approximate pressure atop Everest.) You can fiddle with that a bit by modifying composition and by modifying the people breathing it, but it is a good goal post. This means that for them to be able to walk on the surface without air tanks, the atmosphere has to already have been extensively modified. We are talking at least a 50 fold increase in atmospheric pressure, almost all of which will be a mixture of O2 and your inert gas of choice. CO2 is readily miscible in N2/O2 blends, as well as Noble/O2 blends and the amount of gas you are adding to the atmosphere to get a breathable result means you should get mixing even in canyons and caves, much more so than you would get compression. Again though, I read it as a plot point, not a destructive technical flaw. If I weren’t blogging my impressions of various events in the Bloomington area, I would never have mentioned it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.